Introduction – Welcome to the world of branding, where often the winner isn’t the first off the starting line, but the savvy second-runner.
What does it take to master the market as a brand? Conventional wisdom says you need to sprint ahead of the competition, staking your claim as the bold pioneer blazing new trails. But the truth is, speed and bravado don’t guarantee success. In fact, some of the savviest brands play the long game, biding their time before making a move.
Think of tech juggernauts like Google, Facebook, and Apple. None of them created the hardware or software categories they came to dominate. Instead, they let other companies test the waters first. Once consumer appetite was proven, these clever fast followers revolutionized the marketplace on their own terms with superior products.
In this article, we’ll explore the art of playing second fiddle. Discover why timing, patience and replicating the right ideas at the right moment can help brands gain an edge. We’ll look at the ever-shifting challenges around technology innovation that all brand marketers face today. And we’ll highlight proven strategies used by iconic brands to balance discovery with imitation on their way to the top.
Ready to lead the race by not leading at all? Let’s begin…
The Second-Mover Advantage
They weren’t first, but they won the race anyway. Tech behemoths like Google, Facebook and Microsoft demonstrated the power of the second-mover advantage, transforming entire industries by learning from those who went before them.
Rather than staking early claims, these savvy followers let first-movers test uncharted waters. Once consumer appetite was proven, the fast followers moved in swiftly to outpace the competition. How? By focusing less on bleeding-edge technology, and more on the business models required to dominate.
The Genius of Patient Revolutionaries
In the ever-shifting, hyper-evolving tech landscape, first-movers often sprint ahead only to be overtaken by more patient runners. Just look at search engines. Long before Google, there were pioneers like Altavista, Ask Jeeves and Yahoo blazing trails. What they lacked was the genius of visionaries who could bide their time, then use existing ideas as a springboard for something exponentially better.
Enter Google founders Larry Page and Sergey Brin. Brin compared their strategy to playing “leapfrog”: *”We could see a few pages ahead. It was clear the winner was going to be the one who could lead that leapfrogging process.”* Rather than focus on technology for technology’s sake, Page and Brin zeroed in on building a superior search business.
Steve Jobs epitomized this patient revolutionary approach. With each new product launch for Apple, Jobs took existing innovations and cleverly repackaged them into something irresistible for mainstream consumers. He once said: *”I’m shameless about stealing great ideas.”* This ability to stand on the shoulders of previous giants enabled Apple to consistently transform entire categories.
The Advantages of Hindsight
Unlike headstrong pioneers who rush products to market, second-movers have the luxury of pausing, assessing and refining. Followers mitigate risk by studying earlier iterations, learning from others’ mistakes. With the benefit of hindsight, fast followers like Google, Facebook and Apple tailored offerings for maximum appeal and profit.
Rather than pouring resources into trailblazing technology R&D with no guarantee of success, these savvy second-movers focused on honing business models. Once the market was primed, they strategically scaled up operations to meet demand rapidly. Equipped with well-planned monetization schemes, these dominant followers ultimately dethroned the first-movers they learned so much from in the first place.
So while being first tempts glory-chasers, the advantage goes to those wise enough to resist the urge to run ahead. With a balance of patience and opportunism, second-movers continue leapfrogging their way to the lead.
The Pioneer’s Dilemma: Lead or Follow?
Beyond the tech arena, the choice between trailblazing or biding time applies to brand marketers in any industry. Do you spearhead innovation and risk resources on untested ideas? Or observe from the sidelines as others test the waters first?
This dilemma is far from new. Long before digital disruption, major players like Procter & Gamble faced the pioneer’s conundrum.
Learning Through Smaller Brands
Back in the 1980s, P&G dominated by closely tracking smaller niche innovators entering new product categories. Brands like Texize’s Glass Plus and Spray ‘n Wash identified promising market gaps too modest for P&G. First they validated demand in a controlled setting. Once successful, P&G then followed suit with its own bigger budget versions.
Rather than rushing in, P&G studied these smaller brands as trial runs. After concept testing on a small scale, P&G then leveraged its marketing muscle to eclipse the very pioneers who inspired them. This calculated strategy balanced risk-taking with observation, saving P&G from squandering resources.
The Art of Balancing Discovery and Imitation
Through years of following and learning, P&G nurtured a culture recognizing that breakthrough invention is not the only path to dominance. Yes, P&G commits heavily to spearheading innovation. But the company equally understands the power of imitation – when balanced appropriately with discovery.
Ultimately both invention and imitation prove critical for leading brands. An impatience to trailblaze can drive brands toward untenable risk. Yet excessive conservatism leaves you stuck in the past. The future belongs to those who strike the right equilibrium between the two.
The Pivotal Choice Facing Brands
Beyond scanning for proven ideas, astute followers also recognize when to strategically exit aging technology. Leaders deeply embedded in existing infrastructure face astronomical transition costs. Yet by leapfrogging directly to modern tools, following economies avoid these sunk expenditures.
This very dynamic enables developing regions to catch up rapidly. Unencumbered by legacy systems, areas like Africa adopt cutting-edge solutions like mobile payments. With no prior infrastructure to abandon, developing locales stand poised to realize substantial gains from ongoing technological shifts.
The world’s foremost brands confront a pivotal decision – pioneer new concepts or strategically track validated offerings. At times discovery drives marketplace success. But imitation also warrants strong consideration, provided it is prudently balanced against invention. Ultimately tomorrow’s dominant players will excel at both arts in equal measure.
Balancing Discovery and Imitation
Ultimately, leading brands must balance both invention and imitation. Pioneering new ideas drives progress yet still risks failure. Following validated concepts lowers uncertainty but cedes first-mover profits.
Astute brand marketers artfully blend both approaches. With patience and humility they scan competitive offerings, judiciously adopting proven models. But with vision and boldness they also create wholly original concepts that shift entire industries.
This fusion of discovery and imitation, of both leading and following, enables firms to thrive amid constant disruption. Some brands focus too narrowly on bleeding-edge innovation, missing the power of strategic imitation. Others concentrate excessively on copying others, failing to invent breakthroughs.
To dominate markets, modern brands must do both exceptionally well. They must invent the future through risk-taking new ideas. Yet they must also borrow from the present by efficiently adopting existing advances. Blending these contrary skills distinguishes resilient brands that outmaneuver rivals of all stripes.
Ultimately the path ahead remains unclear – should brands drive progress or leverage it? In truth top firms must skillfully balance both arts. With equal parts vision and pragmatism, they both create the future and borrow from the present. This fusion of invention and imitation becomes the hallmark of those poised to lead their industries for decades on end.
Greetings! I’m Jack, founder of Scythos – where I’ve helped over 50 brands transform into unforgettable identities and stunning digital presences. As a brand strategist and creative consultant, I have over a decade of experience taking brands from wallflowers to the centre of attention.
Looking to get your branding noticed and your business thriving? Reach out anytime to brainstorm creative strategies for making your brand impossible to ignore. I love collaborating with passionate entrepreneurs to conceptualize innovative ways to connect with their audiences.
Whether you need help with a logo, website, content or entire rebrand – let’s chat! I’m always eager to share my ideas, creative concepts and expertise to help brands reach the next level. Together, we can make sure your business gets seen and heard. Follow along on social or send me a message to get the conversation started!